Freelancers vs. Agency VAs: Which One Fits Your Business Best?

RemotelyScale Editorial
Jul 18
4 min read

Hiring a Virtual Assistant can unlock more time, sharper focus, and faster growth for your business—but only if you hire the right kind of support.

With so many options out there, one question stands out: Do you go for a freelancer or an agency-based VA?

Freelancers offer flexibility. Agencies offer structure and support. Both have value—but the best choice depends on how you work, what you need, and where you're headed.

Let’s dive into the real differences—control, cost, risk, and scalability—so you can choose the right path forward. 👇

What’s the Difference Anyway?

Let’s keep it simple:

Freelancers: Independent workers. You handle everything—from hiring and training to setting schedules.
Agency VAs: VAs who are part of a team. They’re trained, supported, and managed by the agency, so you don’t have to do all the heavy lifting.

So which one fits your business best, Freelancer or Agency?

Let’s break it down.

1. Control: Do You Want to Be In Charge of Every Step?

Freelancers give you full control. You decide how things get done, which tools to use, and how to train them. That’s great—if you have the time and energy to manage them.
Agency VAs are already trained and come with a system in place. You don’t have to explain every detail or micromanage.

💡 Tip: If you like creating systems and managing people, freelancing could work. If you’d rather focus on growing your business than teaching someone every step, an agency VA is the smarter path.

2. Cost: Are You Saving Now or Investing in Long-Term Success?

Freelancers often charge less per hour. That looks good at first—but if they quit or miss deadlines, you could lose time and money fast.
Agency VAs cost a bit more, but that price includes training, replacement if needed, support systems, and reliable output.

📌 Smart Move: Paying more for peace of mind and consistent support usually pays off in the long run—especially when your time is your most valuable resource.

3. Skill Level & Scalability: Need One Pair of Hands or a Whole Team?

Freelancers are often skilled in one area—admin, graphics, email, etc. But if you need more services, you’ll have to hire and manage more people.
Agency VAs are part of a bigger team. Want to add a second VA? Need someone with special skills? You can scale quickly—without starting from scratch.

🚀 Growth Hack: Agency VAs are ideal if you're looking to build a team over time. Everything is ready to go, and you’re not left juggling multiple freelancers alone.

A modern office desk setup with a laptop, coffee cup, notebook, pen, eyeglasses, and a calculator, set against a bright city skyline through a large window. Bold turquoise and black text in the center reads "FREELANCER VS. AGENCY," illustrating a comparison between hiring options for virtual assistants.

Quick Look: Freelancers vs. Agency VAs (Similarities and Differences)

Freelancers	Similarities	Agency
Full control, but required hands-on management	Provide remote support	Trained and supported by the agency = less micromanagement
Cheaper upfront, but potential long-term costs if unreliable	Can be highly skilled	Cost include systems, training, and backup = better long-term value
Skill level and professionalism can vary	Help lighten your workload	Consistent skills and standards accross the team
Must hire and train individually for each role	Improve business productivity	Low risk with quick replacement available
Higher risk of ghosting, missed deadlines	Allow flexible arrangements	Handles onboarding, HR, and quality monitoring
You handle everything: onboarding, payroll, oversight

Freelancers Might Be Right For You If…

✅ You’re working on a one-time project

✅ You like being hands-on and managing everything

✅ You’re working with a tight budget

✅ You don’t mind starting from scratch

Agency VAs Might Be Right For You If…

✅ You want long-term, reliable help

✅ You’re ready to grow your business

✅ You don’t want to deal with hiring headaches

✅ You value consistent results and quick support

A realistic photograph of a businessman in his mid-30s wearing a dark suit and tie, seated at a desk with a laptop, resting his chin on his hand in a thoughtful pose. A subtle question mark in a translucent speech bubble hovers above his head, representing decision-making or contemplation in a professional setting. The background shows a modern office space with soft natural light.

Still Deciding? Ask Yourself These Questions:

Do I have time to train and manage someone?
Is this a short project or a long-term role?
Can I handle it if my VA disappears or quits?
Do I want one helper—or a whole team later on?

🧠 Quick Insight: If your business is your full-time focus, a reliable VA from an agency is often a better long-term bet.

There’s no one-size-fits-all. But here’s the truth:

“Freelancers are like buying tools. Agency VAs are like hiring a team to get the job done right.”

If you just need a quick task done, freelancers are fine. But if you’re building something long-term, growing fast, or just don’t want the stress of managing everything—agency-based VAs are your secret weapon.

💼 Need Help Finding the Right Talent?

At RemotelyScale.com, we take the guesswork out of hiring. We connect business owners like you with trained, reliable, and vetted virtual assistants—ready to help you grow.

✅ Payroll, HR, and timekeeping handled for you—for free

✅ No lock-in contracts and no upfront fees

✅ Backup and support included

Connect With Experts Today!

📚 Want to Give Remote Hiring a Try?

Start with our free eBook: No Office, No Limits: Build and Lead Remote Teams on Your Terms

This practical guide shows you how to hire global talent, build a strong remote culture, and lead with confidence—without needing a physical office.

📥 Download it free and get the tools to build a high-performing remote team today.