top of page
rs logo

A Skills Test Should Reveal Talent—Not Become Free Work

Nov 13
6 min read

A skills assessment should help you decide whether someone can do the job. It shouldn't require candidates to do the job before you've hired them.


You've found a promising candidate for a remote marketing position. Their experience looks relevant, the interview goes well, and they seem to understand what the role requires.


Then you send an assessment.


First, you ask for a content strategy. Then a few sample posts. Next, competitor research and a presentation explaining their approach. After that, there are revisions and another round of questions.


Each request might seem reasonable on its own. But put them together, and the candidate may have spent several hours producing work without knowing whether they'll even get the position.


This raises a question worth considering: Are you evaluating someone's ability to do the job, or are you asking them to start doing it for free?


For businesses hiring remote professionals, that distinction matters. A recruitment process should help you make a sound hiring decision. When assessments become excessive, they can work against that goal.


1. The Problem Isn't Skills Testing. It's Assessment Creep.


Hiring someone remotely comes with a practical challenge. You can't always observe how they handle everyday responsibilities before they join your team. A résumé and interview may tell you about someone's experience, but they don't necessarily show how that person approaches the actual work.


That's where skills assessments can help.


The U.S. Office of Personnel Management describes work-sample tests as assessments that ask candidates to perform tasks similar to those they would encounter in the job.


For example:

  • Bookkeeper: Reconcile a short sample of transactions and identify discrepancies.

  • Customer service representative: Respond to a sample customer inquiry.

  • Administrative assistant: Organize a sample schedule with conflicting appointments.

  • Content writer: Write a short piece based on a clearly defined brief.


These exercises give employers something more useful than another conversation about experience. They provide a chance to see how a candidate approaches a relevant task.


The trouble starts when the assessment keeps expanding.


A short writing exercise becomes a complete content plan. A bookkeeping test becomes a detailed financial report. A marketing assignment turns into a competitor analysis, campaign strategy, and presentation.


At that point, employers should ask what additional information they're getting from each extra task.


Research by Zibarras and colleagues (2025) found that candidates generally viewed work-sample and knowledge-based tests positively. Their perceptions of fairness were connected to whether assessments were relevant to the job and gave them a reasonable opportunity to demonstrate their abilities.


The practical lesson for employers is straightforward: an assessment should be relevant enough to reveal capability, but limited enough to remain an assessment.


2. Your Job Description May Be Asking for More Than You Think


Consider a remote administrative assistant position.


The original job advertisement mentions scheduling, email management, and general administrative support. During the recruitment process, candidates discover that the role also involves customer service, social media management, weekly reporting, project coordination, and sales outreach.


A small business may genuinely need someone who can handle several responsibilities. That's not automatically a problem. Many remote roles require flexibility.


But there's a difference between a varied position and a role whose responsibilities keep changing.


When candidates don't know what the job actually involves, they can't properly judge whether they're qualified or interested. Employers, meanwhile, may end up assessing people against expectations that were never clearly communicated.


This can create problems after hiring, too. Someone recruited primarily for administrative work may struggle when the position turns out to require a different skill set.


If a role combines several functions, explain that in the job description. Identify the main responsibilities, distinguish essential skills from additional ones, and be clear about what the person will be expected to handle regularly.


You may attract fewer applicants by being specific. But the applicants who do respond will have a better understanding of the opportunity.


3. An Assessment Shouldn't Become a Substitute for Paid Work


There's a useful question employers can ask before sending any recruitment assignment:


Could we use the candidate's completed work in our business?


Imagine you're hiring a social media specialist. You want to understand how candidates approach content planning and creative decisions.


You could give them a short scenario and ask them to identify a target audience, suggest two content directions, explain their reasoning, and name a metric they would use to evaluate performance.


That gives you insight into their thinking without asking them to build an entire campaign.


Now consider asking for a month's worth of content, finished graphics, a publishing calendar, and a performance strategy. If the company intends to use those materials, the assignment has moved beyond evaluating skills.


A company shouldn't disguise an actual business assignment as a hiring test.


There are also practical costs to excessive assessments:

  • More time spent reviewing: Hiring managers have to evaluate increasingly large submissions.

  • Longer recruitment timelines: Candidates move through additional rounds before receiving a decision.

  • A smaller candidate pool: Experienced professionals may choose not to spend hours on assignments with unclear expectations.

  • Less relevant comparisons: A large submission doesn't automatically make it easier to identify who is best suited to the actual role.


If you need a candidate to produce work that your business intends to use, compensate them appropriately. If you only need to evaluate their ability, design a smaller exercise that answers that question.


4. What a Useful Remote Hiring Assessment Should Look Like


A good assessment doesn't need to be complicated. It needs to give you information that helps you make a hiring decision.


Before sending one, consider five things:


1. Does it reflect the actual job?

Test the responsibilities the person will handle, not unrelated skills that happen to be easy to assess.


2. Can candidates complete it in a reasonable amount of time?

Tell applicants how long the exercise should take. If the task requires several hours, reconsider whether you need that much work to evaluate the skill.


3. Do you know what a good answer looks like?

Set evaluation criteria before reviewing submissions. For example, are you looking at accuracy, communication, problem-solving, attention to detail, or the ability to follow instructions?


4. Are you giving candidates a fair basis for comparison?

Use consistent instructions and evaluation standards. Otherwise, you may end up comparing candidates who were given different opportunities to demonstrate their abilities.


5. Are you assessing ability or collecting deliverables?

A candidate's work should help you understand how they approach a task. If you're asking for something your business can immediately put into production, consider whether it should be a paid assignment instead.


These questions won't make every hiring decision easy. They will, however, help keep the assessment focused on what matters.


5. The Recruitment Process Is Part of the Candidate Experience

For businesses hiring remote professionals, recruitment is often the first experience a candidate has with the company.


They notice how clearly the role is explained, how organized the process feels, how long decisions take, and whether their time is respected.


That experience can influence whether they continue with the application.


Good candidates have choices. If a recruitment process involves repeated assignments, unclear expectations, and long periods without feedback, some will simply move on.


That leaves employers spending more time searching and assessing, while potentially losing people who could have been a good fit.


At RemotelyScale, we believe the starting point should be understanding the work a business actually needs done. That means identifying the responsibilities, skills, and level of support required before matching those needs with remote professionals.


The goal isn't to make recruitment longer or more complicated. It's to make sure the evaluation reflects the position and gives both sides a clearer understanding of what to expect.


The Best Hiring Test Is One That Knows When to Stop


If a candidate needs to complete five assignments just to demonstrate they can handle a straightforward responsibility, it may be time to reconsider the assessment.


More tasks don't necessarily produce better hiring decisions. Sometimes they only make the process longer.


Employers need enough information to judge a candidate's ability, but they also need to recognize when they already have it.


A well-designed assessment respects the employer's need to make a good decision and the candidate's time and effort.


A skills test should reveal talent—not become unpaid work.


Looking for Remote Professionals Who Match Your Business Requirements?


Finding someone to fill a job title is only the beginning. You need someone whose skills and experience match the responsibilities your business needs handled.


RemotelyScale helps businesses identify their staffing requirements and connect with qualified remote professionals through a structured sourcing and screening approach.


Visit RemotelyScale.com to learn more.


References


1. Zibarras, L. D., et al. (2025). Applicant perceptions of selection methods: Replicating and extending previous research. International Journal of Selection and Assessment, 33(2). https://doi.org/10.1111/ijsa.70007


2. U.S. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission. (n.d.). Employment tests and selection procedures. https://www.eeoc.gov/laws/guidance/employment-tests-and-selection-procedures



4. U.S. Office of Personnel Management. (n.d.). Designing an assessment strategy. https://www.opm.gov/policy-data-oversight/assessment-and-selection/assessment-strategy


Editorial note: The article intentionally does not claim that unpaid assessments are automatically illegal. The concern is their scope, relevance, transparency, and whether actual business deliverables are being obtained without a proper working arrangement.

 

Comments


bottom of page